If you want a good chuckle, check out this collection of rants against soccer and youth soccer from the National Review. It never ceases to amaze me that these people get paid to write this stuff. Some of my favorites quotes include:
There is no surer sign of the decline of America’s culture than the craze over this awful European sport. Drive past a park or a schoolyard on a clear spring afternoon and you’re likely to witness a depressingly unpatriotic sight: the baseball diamond lies empty and crab grass grows in the infield, while herds of American children dressed in preposterous polyester uniforms run around kicking a white and black ball in no particular direction and to no apparent end.
Can someone explain to me how it’s unpatriotic that ‘herds of American children’ are having fun running around no matter what they’re wearing? It gets better.
I am convinced that the ordeal of soccer teaches our kids all the wrong lessons in life. Soccer is the Marxist concept of the labor theory of value applied to sports — which may explain why socialist nations dominate in the World Cup. The purpose of a capitalist economy is to produce the maximum output for the least amount of exertion. Soccer requires huge volumes of effort but produces no output.
Wait – what? Baseball scores rarely exceed 10. If we got 7 points for a goal in soccer, you’d think they were American football scores. And this makes us Marxist? Of course it wouldn’t be a good National Review rant without some sexism:
What makes peewee soccer particularly insidious is that boys and girls play together. At this level, the sport has become a giant social experiment imposed upon us by the same geniuses who have put women in combat. No one seems to care much that co-ed soccer is doing irreparable harm to the psyche of America’s little boys.
At this pre-puberty state of life girls tower over boys and typically have better coordination. Last year the Pele of my son’s league was a kindergartner named Kate Lynn. During one game, Kate Lynn repeatedly stampeded over Justin. After the third knockdown, I quietly pulled him aside and advised: “Remember that rule about never hitting a girl? Let’s suspend that for the next forty minutes.” But he never did, because she was likely to hit back.
Um – just wow. And that was only from the first article. Keep reading if you can. The mind boggles.
H/T yhatemetoo
May 22nd, 2008 at 4:55 pm
Just came across your site, and this is the first post I read. Hilarious! How can people take issue with today’s youth having a healthy outlet? Team building, fitness, persistence, and self-motivation are lessons learned in every sport- especially soccer.
May 22nd, 2008 at 10:01 pm
Welcome Jillian! I find a lot of these soccer rants are just people who choose to make judgments about youth soccer without getting to know it. People who think soccer is some sissy sport where kids don’t play to win have never been to a select/travel match (or a Rec match in some leagues!) What annoys me more is when they quote completely incorrect information. 3 million kids playing in soccer leagues? That figure is just for the USYSA I believe. Recent estimates of all kids playing soccer of some sort are close to 17 million!
May 23rd, 2008 at 11:38 am
The author of the article is an ass. My son’s middle school soccer team lost only one match all season. Thats schools baseball coach called those players “foot fairies”. I told the coach that I bet he feels like a “real man telling young kids that while in the locker room”. I also asked what’s it like being a middle school gym teacher and I guess it’s the only job a loser like him could get. I also told him when he addresses me call me “Dr. XXXXXXX” since I earned that degree. It shut the jerk-off up in one second.
Sorry to rant…
May 24th, 2008 at 9:29 am
I just found your site, also. What a hoot! All three of my boys have played and excelled at soccer, along with being top notch in academics and leaders in the community. Back when we were considering a sport for our oldest (now 19) we went and observed a little league softball game of 4 year-olds, along with a soccer game of 4 year-olds. We were sickened by the anger, frustration, yelling and nastiness demonstrated by more than one softball parent and delighted to see the positive support (even between parents of opposite teams)at the soccer game. We posed the question to our pediatrician who emphatically recommended soccer for the high level of activity, involvement of all players and great cardiovascular workout. We chose soccer for our under 5, and it has been a love story ever since. I just chuckle when I hear comments of idiocy like you quote. Chuckle, and look at my strong, athletic, well-rounded, and happy sons…
May 27th, 2008 at 9:46 am
Bill, I am still amazed at how many other youth sport coaches view soccer. Our coaches bend over backwards to try and accomodate other sports their kids may play. It usually comes down to which sport has the more important event going on on a given day. I would have no problem if one of my players missed a soccer practice to play in a basketball tournament or baseball game when they overlapped. But all too often I have other coaches telling players they won’t play in a game if they miss practice to play in a soccer game. Heck we had one coach tell a kid if they missed softball practice for soccer travel team tryouts – they wouldn’t play that weekend. Nice lesson to teach coach. The kid quit the softball team and tried out.
I’m not saying all coaches are like this, but I find all too often that coaches in other sports expect kids to pass up soccer for *their* sport. I guess that a natural reaction, but I see this a lot less among the soccer coaches and the league makes clear to coaches to be accommodating. Yet you get the feeling coaches view soccer as some leisure activity and I don’t think many realize how hard these kids work and how physical the matches can be. They’re kids people – that want to have fun at different sports – you should support that.
Just like high school baseball and football coaches who fight to keep the soccer teams from using ‘their fields’ like somehow the kids playing soccer don’t deserve to have a field to play on. Very annoying.
May 27th, 2008 at 9:56 am
Stacy,
Welcome! Hope you enjoy OTP and tell your friends! 🙂
All sports have crazy parents. I’ve seen my share in soccer. But I’ve also seen much more hard nosed coaches in things like baseball, where kids are often benched, shoved in right field, etc – in ‘Rec’ levels. Yes, soccer can be a bit to much of a ‘touchy feely’ sport at younger age levels – but the idea is for kids to HAVE FUN – and help ensure the kids can play as long as they like. If they want more competition, they move up as they get older.
What I’ve found interesting is how crazy soccer parents get more media attention than those of other sports (at least it seems that way). I’ve never understood that. One thing for sure is that soccer seems to foster much more of a community atmosphere among the parents overall. You always have tension and drama here and there – but other sports seem less likely to foster friendships and acquaintances. You come, watch the event, and leave, talking little to those around you.
Like you, I think soccer has been a great activity for our kids because it’s so much more than just a sport – for them and us. We’ve all made more friends in soccer than in other sports – just how it went for us. I’m sure other sports foster friendships and such, but I’ve not found it with basketball. YMMV.
But braindead writings like these, albeit a few years old, just amaze me at how close minded people can be. I love the folks who think soccer is a non-contact sport – they’re the first to complain about it being a sissy sport and then the first to complain when their kid gets cleanly tackled or bodied off the ball when they get older.
May 27th, 2008 at 2:22 pm
Hilariously ridiculous, seems as though the writer has too much time on his hands. I do take issue that he told his boy to hit the girl too; whenever another player plays rough against my son I tell him that the best retaliation is to score a goal and ignore the pushing and shoving.