A win is a win. Was the MLS All-Star game a warm-up for Chelsea? Sure. Are most All-Star matches in various sports more about exposure and less about intense play? Of course. Did the result mean anything significant? Probably not. But someone forgot to tell the MLS All-Stars and Peter Nowak. They played a tough match and put in a gritty performance in front of a decent sized (by US standards) crowd if 21,000+. And while this may not have mattered to Chelsea, they sure played like it did in the last 5 minutes of regulation when they turned up the tempo noticeably. Jeff Carlisle summed it up nicely on SoccerNet:
At the beginning of the match, the vast majority of fans seemed smitten with their English guests, cheering their every move. But with each tackle and each completed pass by the "home" team, the crowd was soon won over, to the point that chants of "USA! USA!" became more common than the roars of "Chelsea!" Given the blue-collar attitude displayed by the players, why not? This was the kind of performance that fans were hoping to see from the U.S. national team at the World Cup, but didn’t get. And as Saturday’s game progressed, the more the All-Stars battled, the more fans hitched along for the ride.
[emphasis mine] Reminds me of what I tell my U10 kids all the time. It doesn’t matter if we win or lose, it’s how we played the game. (bad cliche I know) If we gave our best effort on the pitch and still lose, that’s OK the wins will come. A ‘bad’ performance isn’t a loss, it’s a lackluster performance.
I think Aaron Gidding is a bit over the top saying this is the ‘Best Year in US Soccer‘. But change is afoot, you can feel it. The MLS All-Stars played hard and fought to win a ‘meaningless match’ against a renowned European team. That’s not meaningless. It speaks volumes.
August 7th, 2006 at 7:16 am
Great post Soccer Dad! It is a step in the right direction and many more need to be taken for MLS. Unfortunately, we Americans are spoiled with having 3 of the Top Sports Properties in the World with EPL being the 4th.
I could not agree with you more that, “it’s how we played the game”. MLS players must consistently do this to grab fans attention. Unfortunatley, we really missed out by proving this on the big stage (World Cup). However, the All-Star match is a step in the right direction – even if small its a good step.
Ciao,
Jason
August 8th, 2006 at 2:10 pm
I enjoyed watching that game. I tried to get some people to come over to watch with me but that didn’t work out; guess I should ask sooner than the afternoon of… still, it was pretty cool. This point about the crowd’s allegiance shifting is a really interesting one. For me there was no question I’d root for the MLS team; however, there was a bit of cognitive dissonance involved going against Shevchenko and Ballack and all the rest. Also, what’s with Ballack’s new haircut??? He needs to grow it back the way it was pronto!
The announcing was painful, did you find this also? There was Eric Wynalda trying to explain the concept of transfer fees to Dave O’Brien, and O’Brien not getting it, and then there was Eric Wynalda bragging about how cool it was to be hanging out at a bar with Michael Ballack (and me unsuccessfully trying to telepathically beam SHUT UP ERIC SHUT UP ERIC YOU ARE AN EMBARRASSMENT TO ALL AMERICANS at him) and then… Brandi Chastain (with her shirt on) was interviewing the coaches in the middle of the game, while they were supposed to be, you know, coaching? Just… oy.
But, other than that, it was a good game. 🙂
August 8th, 2006 at 2:18 pm
I was impressed with how many blue shirts I saw in the crowd – I think that’s great. Nothing says MLS has to have some monopoly over US fans.
I missed most of the commentary – I have 4 kids, it was dinner time, it was a weekend, they were, um, energetic. I just watched the game with the volume down low drowned out by the mayhem that surrounded me 🙂
I like Eric Wynalda as a studio commentator, but you just knew he’d start to call more games since his studio stint seemed to be well received by folks. I don’t think his demeanor and style fit with play by play. As for Dave O not getting the concept of transfer fees – color me shocked 🙂
/me resists with every fiber of his being a snappy comeback about Brandi, shirts, and attracting more soccer fans 🙂 Seriously though I still have never understood why people got SO freaked out about it after they won – I mean she was wearing something that was 2 inches away from a tank top – it wasn’t like it was a bikini. Sheesh people.
August 8th, 2006 at 2:40 pm
I’ve heard that joke before, as have we all – but I loved Brandi for celebrating that way, because she “sold it” as Marcelo Needs-a-Haircut would say. What I mean is that she made it seem completely natural and normal for a woman to do something – taking her shirt off to celebrate a goal – that was seen by the entire world as an exclusively male prerogative. This was around the time that I was in 7th grade and wanted to play soccer in the World Cup… the Men’s World Cup. No supposedly-lesser all-women teams for me. (They didn’t exist in my town anyway; I had to play with boys if I played at all.) At that time in my life I was just starting to run up against the boundaries men draw around women’s lives, but Brandi was carrying on with her life as if they didn’t exist. I’ll never forget that and I’ll always love her for it.
August 8th, 2006 at 2:48 pm
Agree 100% – It was a great moment. There’s something karmic about the success of the women’s national team compared to our men’s team. (/me gently closes the cover on that can…)
I’m actually messing around with a post delving into youth teams and Co-ed vs gender segregated (something Footie Girl talked about a weke or two ago). I’m hope you’ll have lots to add!
August 8th, 2006 at 3:01 pm
Wow, I just did some googling and I’m completely misremembering dates and conflating things, unless she took her shirt off other times. I was way past junior high in 1999. 🙂